What is Rule 56 and how does it govern summary judgment? Learn the legal framework behind summary judgment motions and how Legal Husk helps litigants meet Rule 56 standards.

Understanding Rule 56: The Legal Standard for Summary Judgment

Introduction

Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure is the foundation of summary judgment practice in federal court. It allows parties to ask the court to resolve a case—or parts of it—without a trial, based solely on the legal sufficiency of the evidence.

Understanding Rule 56 is essential for any party seeking to win or defeat a summary judgment motion. This article breaks down Rule 56’s text, purpose, and application and offers tips on how to meet its requirements with strong evidence and legal arguments.

Need a court-ready motion or opposition brief drafted under Rule 56? Visit legalhusk.com or legalhusk.com/services/civil-litigation.

What Is Rule 56?

Rule 56 is the rule in federal court that governs summary judgment—a legal mechanism to avoid trial when there is no genuine dispute of material fact.

Text of Rule 56(a):

“The court shall grant summary judgment if the movant shows that there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.”

Purpose:

• Promote efficiency by resolving legally insufficient claims
• Narrow the issues for trial
• Encourage early resolution where facts are undisputed

Key Concepts in Rule 56

1. Genuine Dispute

• Means a real and substantial conflict, not a minor or speculative disagreement
• A dispute that could affect the outcome of the case

2. Material Fact

• A fact that must be proven to establish a party’s claim or defense
• Irrelevant facts do not defeat summary judgment

3. Entitled to Judgment as a Matter of Law

• The legal standard must favor the moving party based on the undisputed facts

Who Can File Under Rule 56?

• Plaintiffs may file if the defendant’s liability is clear
• Defendants often file to dismiss meritless or unprovable claims
• Both sides can file cross-motions

A motion can address the entire case or just certain claims or defenses (partial summary judgment).

Rule 56(c): What Must Be Included in the Motion

• Statement of undisputed material facts
• Supporting citations to:
  • Depositions
  • Affidavits or declarations
  • Documents and electronically stored information
  • Admissions

The court can consider only admissible evidence.

Rule 56(d): What If You Need More Discovery?

A party may request that the court defer ruling on the motion if:

• More time is needed to gather facts
• Discovery is incomplete

File a Rule 56(d) affidavit or declaration explaining:

• Why the evidence is unavailable
• What discovery is needed
• How it may affect the outcome

What Happens When a Rule 56 Motion Is Filed?

The Court Will:

• Review each fact and citation
• Determine if any material facts are genuinely disputed
• Apply the correct law to the undisputed facts
• Decide whether to grant or deny the motion

If Granted:

• The claims addressed in the motion are resolved
• Judgment may be entered (full or partial)

If Denied:

• The case proceeds to trial on the disputed issues

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Filing without sufficient evidence
• Arguing law without tying it to the facts
• Submitting unauthenticated or inadmissible exhibits
• Ignoring the opposing party’s evidence

How Rule 56 Applies in State Courts

Most states have a state-law equivalent to Rule 56:

• California: CCP 437c
• New York: CPLR 3212
• Florida: Rule 1.510

These rules follow similar principles but may differ in procedural requirements.

How Legal Husk Can Help

At Legal Husk, we:

• Draft Rule 56-compliant summary judgment motions and responses
• Prepare affidavits, fact statements, and exhibit lists
• Identify undisputed material facts and legal standards
• Help clients respond with Rule 56(d) declarations if discovery is needed

📌 Learn more:

• legalhusk.com
• legalhusk.com/services
• legalhusk.com/services/civil-litigation
• legalhusk.com/about-us

Final Thoughts

Rule 56 gives parties the opportunity to resolve cases based on the law and evidence—without trial. Mastering this rule is essential to strategic litigation. Whether you’re the moving party or opposing it, knowing the nuances of Rule 56 can make all the difference.

📩 Need help drafting a Rule 56 motion or response? Visit Legal Husk to purchase professional court-ready summary judgment documents.