Preparing your clients for the potential outcomes of a summary judgment decision is crucial. Learn how to manage client expectations and ensure they understand the implications of the court’s decision.
Summary judgment motions can have a significant impact on the outcome of a case. If granted, the motion can resolve the dispute early, saving time and resources for both parties. However, if denied, it can lead to prolonged litigation and increased costs. For this reason, it is essential for attorneys to effectively prepare their clients for the potential outcomes of a summary judgment decision.
In this article, Legal Husk provides insights on how to prepare clients for the impact of summary judgment decisions. This includes managing expectations, explaining the potential consequences, and advising clients on the next steps after the decision.
✅ The first step in preparing your client for a summary judgment decision is to clearly explain what summary judgment is and the potential outcomes. Many clients may not be familiar with this legal procedure, so it’s essential to ensure they understand its role in the litigation process.
What Is Summary Judgment?: Explain to your client that summary judgment is a motion filed to request that the court rule on a case without going to trial. This is done when one party believes that the facts are undisputed and that the law clearly supports their position.
Example: "A summary judgment motion is used when we believe the evidence is so clear that a trial is unnecessary. We are asking the judge to decide the case based on the law and the facts as we’ve presented them."
Possible Outcomes: Help your client understand the possible outcomes of a summary judgment motion, including the chance of the case being resolved early (if granted) or proceeding to trial (if denied).
Example: "If the judge grants the summary judgment motion, your case may be resolved without going to trial. If the motion is denied, the case will continue to trial, and we will have more opportunities to present evidence."
🎯 Strategic Tip: Set clear expectations by explaining the purpose of the motion and the potential consequences of both a grant and denial.
✅ It’s important to manage your client’s expectations realistically based on the strength of the case. If you’re confident that the motion for summary judgment has strong legal grounds and evidence, you may be able to give your client a better idea of the likely outcome. Conversely, if the motion faces significant challenges, it’s important to be transparent about the risks.
Strong Case for Summary Judgment: If the case has a solid foundation for summary judgment, explain to your client that the motion has a strong chance of success. However, be clear that even strong motions can be denied, and factors beyond the evidence, such as legal nuances or judicial preferences, may play a role.
Example: "We have a strong case for summary judgment because the facts are clear and well-documented. I believe the chances of success are high, but we must be prepared for the possibility that the judge may see things differently."
Weak Case for Summary Judgment: If the case faces challenges—such as disputed facts or weak legal arguments—be honest with your client about the likelihood of the motion being denied. Help them understand that while a denial isn’t the end, it may result in a more prolonged and expensive litigation process.
Example: "The opposing party has raised some valid points, and there’s a real possibility that the judge may deny our motion. If that happens, we’ll need to proceed to trial, but we will continue to fight for a favorable outcome."
🎯 Strategic Tip: Be transparent about the case’s strengths and weaknesses to help clients understand the realistic chances of success and prepare them for the next steps.
✅ A summary judgment decision can have significant emotional and financial implications for your client. Whether the decision is favorable or not, it’s important to address the potential consequences and help your client prepare for the impact.
For Clients Who Win: If the summary judgment motion is granted in favor of your client, this can bring relief and a sense of victory. However, it’s important to remind them that there may still be post-judgment motions, appeals, or enforcement actions to consider.
Example: "If we win, it will be a big victory for you, but we should remain aware that the other side may appeal the decision, so the case may not be fully over."
For Clients Who Lose: If the motion is denied, the emotional toll of continuing litigation can be significant, particularly for clients who hoped for an early resolution. It’s important to guide them through the next steps and reassure them that you will continue to advocate for them.
Example: "If the judge denies our motion, it will be a setback, but this is not the end. We will move forward with trial preparation, and I will continue to fight for the best possible outcome."
For Clients Who Win: Winning a summary judgment motion may result in significant financial benefits, such as avoiding trial costs and securing a favorable judgment. However, it’s important to explain that there may still be costs associated with post-judgment procedures, such as enforcement or settlement negotiations.
Example: "Winning the motion means we can avoid the high costs of trial, but we should still be prepared for possible appeals or the need to negotiate a settlement."
For Clients Who Lose: Losing the summary judgment motion can lead to continued litigation, including the costs of going to trial. Be prepared to discuss the financial aspects of proceeding to trial, including the costs of discovery, expert witnesses, and trial preparation.
Example: "If the motion is denied, we will need to proceed with trial preparation, which will involve additional costs. I will make sure we are fully prepared to present the strongest case at trial."
🎯 Strategic Tip: Discuss the emotional and financial aspects of the ruling with your client to help them prepare for the immediate and long-term consequences.
✅ After the court has ruled on the summary judgment motion, it’s essential to guide your client on the next steps, whether the ruling is favorable or unfavorable. Discussing the future course of action helps your client stay informed and focused on the goals ahead.
Finalize the Case: If the motion is granted, discuss any next steps required to finalize the case, such as post-judgment motions or enforcement of the judgment. If the case involves a settlement, this may also be the time to discuss finalizing terms.
Example: "Now that the summary judgment motion has been granted, we will prepare for any necessary post-judgment motions or work on finalizing a settlement if applicable."
Prepare for Appeals: If the opposing party files an appeal, help your client understand the process and potential outcomes.
Example: "The other side may appeal, and we’ll need to prepare for that process. I’ll guide you through the steps and keep you updated on any developments."
Prepare for Trial: If the motion is denied, it’s crucial to prepare your client for the trial process. This includes discussing the trial schedule, potential outcomes, and ongoing costs.
Example: "We’ll need to prepare for trial now, and I’ll work with you to ensure we’re fully ready. Let’s start gathering all of our evidence and get ready for the next phase."
Consider Settlement Negotiations: After a motion is denied, settlement negotiations may be a viable option. Discuss whether settling the case at this point might be advantageous.
Example: "If we’re unable to win on summary judgment, settlement may still be an option. I’ll keep you informed about any offers and help you assess your best course of action."
🎯 Strategic Tip: Be clear and proactive about next steps, guiding your client through the potential challenges and opportunities that may arise after the summary judgment ruling.
Preparing your clients for the potential outcomes of a summary judgment decision is an essential part of managing their expectations and ensuring they remain informed throughout the litigation process. Whether the decision is favorable or unfavorable, your role as an attorney is to provide clear guidance on the next steps, help manage the emotional and financial impact, and continue advocating for the best possible outcome.
At Legal Husk, we help litigators manage client expectations, provide clear guidance on summary judgment outcomes, and ensure that clients understand the potential consequences of each decision.
📌 Need assistance in preparing your clients for the impact of a summary judgment decision?
👉 Visit:
🔗 legalhusk.com
🔗 legalhusk.com/services
📩 Ready for a court-ready motion for summary judgment at a predictable price? Contact Legal Husk for expert support.
File wisely. Litigate efficiently—Legal Husk.
Whether you are dealing with a complex family matter, facing criminal charges, or navigating the intricacies of business law, our mission is to provide you with comprehensive, compassionate, and expert legal guidance.
