Summary judgment motions can greatly influence your discovery strategy. Learn how to align discovery with the potential for summary judgment to maximize efficiency and case outcomes.

Discovery is a crucial phase in litigation, where both parties gather evidence to support their claims and defenses. When a motion for summary judgment is anticipated or already filed, it can significantly shape your discovery strategy. The goal is to gather only the evidence that will support or oppose the motion, rather than overloading the case with unnecessary information. A strategic approach to discovery can increase the chances of success in summary judgment, allowing parties to address key issues early in the litigation process.

In this article, Legal Husk explores how summary judgment influences discovery, how to shape your discovery strategy accordingly, and key considerations for managing the discovery process when summary judgment is on the horizon.

1. The Timing of Discovery in Summary Judgment Cases

✅ The timing of discovery plays a significant role in preparing for summary judgment. If summary judgment is filed before discovery is complete, it’s essential to understand how to approach the discovery phase to support your motion.

Key Considerations:

• Accelerated Discovery: If you anticipate a summary judgment motion, you may want to accelerate discovery to ensure you have all the facts in place before filing. This includes taking depositions, gathering documents, and preparing expert reports.

  • Example: "In the case of Smith v. Jones, the defendant accelerated discovery to secure vital documents and expert testimony to support their motion for summary judgment."

• Limit Discovery to Material Facts: Discovery should be focused on the material facts that will influence the outcome of the motion. Avoid expansive discovery that may lead to unnecessary information or disputes that could delay the case.

  • Example: "Plaintiff limited discovery to the specific contractual terms in dispute, which were central to the defendant's summary judgment motion."

• Early Summary Judgment Motion: In some cases, filing a summary judgment motion early can limit the need for further discovery. If there is a lack of factual dispute, the motion can narrow the scope of discovery, focusing only on the issues that matter.

  • Example: "Defendant filed an early summary judgment motion based on a lack of material facts, which ultimately narrowed the scope of discovery to contract terms and correspondence."

🎯 Strategic Tip: Be proactive in setting discovery timelines to align with your summary judgment goals, ensuring that the evidence needed for your motion is gathered efficiently.

2. Tailoring Discovery to Support a Motion for Summary Judgment

✅ Once you know that a motion for summary judgment is part of your strategy, it's crucial to tailor your discovery efforts to directly support your claims or challenge your opponent’s motion.

Discovery Methods to Focus On:

• Requesting Specific Documents: Focus on documents that are most relevant to the legal issues involved in the summary judgment motion, such as contracts, communications, and other key pieces of evidence.

  • Example: "Defendant requested specific emails from the plaintiff, which were critical in showing that the plaintiff’s claims were inconsistent with prior communications."

• Depositions: If the summary judgment motion hinges on witness testimony, depositions are crucial. Use depositions to lock in witness statements and ensure there is no material dispute over key facts.

  • Example: "Plaintiff deposed the defendant's key witnesses to ensure their testimonies would align with the facts supporting their motion for summary judgment."

• Interrogatories: Use interrogatories to get written responses from the other party that can be used to support your motion. These written responses may help establish undisputed facts or clarify issues that can be addressed in summary judgment.

  • Example: "The plaintiff used interrogatories to establish that the defendant had no written contract, which was central to their summary judgment motion."

🎯 Strategic Tip: Focus your discovery efforts on gathering evidence that directly addresses the issues raised in the motion for summary judgment. This will ensure that the facts are aligned with your legal arguments.

3. How Summary Judgment Encourages Narrowing the Focus of Discovery

✅ One of the key features of summary judgment is that it focuses on undisputed material facts. This forces both parties to narrow their focus during discovery, making it a more efficient and focused process.

Narrowing Discovery to Key Issues:

• Limit Scope to Key Legal Elements: When preparing for summary judgment, discovery should focus on the facts that directly impact the legal elements of the case. For example, in a breach of contract case, discovery should focus on the existence of the contract and the defendant’s performance.

  • Example: "In a breach of contract motion for summary judgment, discovery was focused on emails and documents that outlined the terms of the agreement and any alleged breaches."

• Avoid Overly Broad Discovery Requests: Instead of requesting a wide range of documents, make discovery requests that are targeted to the core issues that could result in a motion for summary judgment. This will save time and money while ensuring you gather only the most relevant evidence.

  • Example: "Defendant focused discovery on correspondence and documents related to the specific dispute at hand, rather than asking for all internal emails related to the company’s operations."

• Address Factual Disputes Early: If you anticipate factual disputes, narrow discovery to those specific issues to ensure that they are resolved before the motion is filed. This will help streamline the summary judgment process.

  • Example: "Plaintiff used discovery to clarify the timeline of events, ensuring that there was no factual dispute regarding the delivery of goods, which was central to the motion for summary judgment."

🎯 Strategic Tip: Narrow your discovery to the most critical issues to avoid wasting time on irrelevant information and ensure a more efficient path to summary judgment.

4. Discovery Disputes and Summary Judgment Motions

✅ Discovery disputes can arise when one party believes that the other is not providing the necessary information to resolve key factual issues. In the context of a summary judgment motion, resolving these disputes early is essential to avoid delays.

Handling Discovery Disputes:

• Motion to Compel Discovery: If the opposing party is withholding documents or evidence relevant to the motion for summary judgment, you may need to file a motion to compel to ensure that discovery proceeds on schedule.

  • Example: "Plaintiff filed a motion to compel when defendant failed to provide critical documents that were needed to support the motion for summary judgment."

• Protecting Confidential Information: If confidential information is involved, consider using protective orders or limiting discovery to only the necessary documents to avoid unnecessary disputes over disclosure.

  • Example: "Defendant requested a protective order to prevent the disclosure of proprietary business information, ensuring that the summary judgment motion focused on the relevant contract details."

• Addressing Incomplete or Insufficient Responses: If the opposing party’s responses to discovery requests are insufficient or incomplete, follow up to ensure that you receive all the necessary information to proceed with your motion.

  • Example: "After receiving incomplete deposition responses, Plaintiff issued follow-up questions to clarify key facts, which were critical for their summary judgment motion."

🎯 Strategic Tip: Anticipate potential discovery disputes and address them early to avoid delays in your summary judgment process.

5. Timing Discovery with a Motion for Summary Judgment

✅ Timing is a key factor when discovery and summary judgment are involved. If you plan to file a motion for summary judgment, ensure that discovery is completed early enough to give the judge the facts needed to rule on the motion.

Tips for Timing Discovery:

• Start Discovery Early: Begin discovery as soon as possible after filing the complaint, so you have sufficient time to gather the evidence needed for summary judgment.

• Coordinate Discovery with Summary Judgment Deadlines: Ensure that discovery is completed well before the deadline for filing the summary judgment motion, so you have all the facts and documents you need to support your position.

• Adjust Discovery to Motion Deadlines: If summary judgment is likely or already in the planning stages, consider narrowing the scope of discovery to ensure the most critical issues are addressed in a timely manner.

  • Example: "The defendant completed discovery early to allow sufficient time to prepare their motion for summary judgment, ensuring that all the necessary facts were available for their legal argument."

🎯 Strategic Tip: Plan discovery timelines carefully to ensure that all critical evidence is gathered in time to support your motion for summary judgment.

Final Thoughts

Summary judgment has a significant impact on the discovery phase, shaping how and when evidence is gathered. By tailoring your discovery strategy to align with your motion for summary judgment, you can streamline the process, reduce unnecessary costs, and ensure that your motion is well-supported with the relevant facts. Properly navigating the timing and scope of discovery will improve your chances of success in obtaining summary judgment.

At Legal Husk, we assist litigators in developing discovery strategies that complement their summary judgment goals, ensuring that evidence is gathered efficiently and effectively.

Let Legal Husk Help You Shape Your Discovery Strategy

📌 Need help aligning your discovery strategy with your summary judgment motion?

👉 Visit:
🔗 legalhusk.com
🔗 legalhusk.com/services

📩 Ready for a court-ready motion for summary judgment at a predictable price? Contact Legal Husk for expert support.

File wisely. Litigate efficiently—Legal Husk.