Motions to dismiss and summary judgment motions both aim to end litigation early, but they work differently. Learn the key distinctions between these two powerful legal tools.

Both motions to dismiss and motions for summary judgment are designed to dispose of a case before it reaches trial. However, they serve different purposes and are used at different stages in the litigation process. Understanding these differences can help attorneys choose the appropriate strategy based on the facts of the case.

In this article, Legal Husk explains the key differences between motions to dismiss and motions for summary judgment, helping you decide when and how to use each tool effectively.

1. What is a Motion to Dismiss?

✅ A motion to dismiss is typically filed at the early stages of litigation, often before the defendant answers the complaint. It asks the court to dismiss the case based on procedural or legal deficiencies in the plaintiff’s complaint.

• Grounds for a Motion to Dismiss:

  • Failure to state a claim (Rule 12(b)(6))

  • Lack of jurisdiction

  • Improper venue

  • Failure to exhaust administrative remedies

  • Insufficient service of process

🎯 The key factor in a motion to dismiss is that the court assumes all facts in the complaint are true, and the defendant argues that the complaint, even if true, does not state a valid legal claim.

2. What is a Motion for Summary Judgment?

✅ A motion for summary judgment is filed later in the case, typically after discovery, and asks the court to rule in favor of one party because there are no genuine issues of material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.

• Grounds for Summary Judgment:

  • There is sufficient evidence in the record to prove that one party is entitled to judgment.

  • The facts are undisputed, or the dispute over facts is not significant to the legal issues at hand.

🎯 The key factor in a motion for summary judgment is that evidence is presented, and the moving party argues that, based on the facts and law, they should win the case.

3. Key Differences Between a Motion to Dismiss and a Motion for Summary Judgment

1. Timing

• Motion to Dismiss: Typically filed early in the case, often right after the complaint is filed, but before the defendant answers or discovery occurs.

• Motion for Summary Judgment: Filed later, typically after the discovery phase when both parties have had the opportunity to gather and present evidence.

2. Standard of Review

• Motion to Dismiss: The court reviews the complaint to determine whether it states a valid legal claim, assuming the facts alleged are true.

• Motion for Summary Judgment: The court reviews the evidence in the record, including depositions, documents, and affidavits, to determine if there are any genuine disputes of material fact.

3. Purpose

• Motion to Dismiss: Seeks to end the case early based on legal insufficiency in the complaint.

• Motion for Summary Judgment: Seeks to end the case based on undisputed facts and the law that favors the moving party.

4. Evidence Considered

• Motion to Dismiss: Only the allegations in the complaint and any exhibits attached to the complaint are considered.

• Motion for Summary Judgment: The court considers the entire evidentiary record, including depositions, documents, and expert testimony.

4. When to Use a Motion to Dismiss vs. Summary Judgment

✅ Understanding when to use each motion is essential to crafting a strategic litigation approach:

• Use a Motion to Dismiss when:

  • The complaint fails to state a claim (e.g., the allegations are vague, legally insufficient, or do not meet the required pleading standards).

  • There are jurisdictional issues, such as a lack of personal or subject matter jurisdiction.

  • The venue is improper, and the case should be heard in a different court.

• Use a Motion for Summary Judgment when:

  • Discovery is complete, and the facts are undisputed, making it clear that one party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.

  • There is sufficient evidence to support your position, and you want the court to decide the case based on those facts.

  • The plaintiff has failed to provide evidence to support their claims, and no reasonable jury could find in their favor.

5. Example of Motion to Dismiss vs. Motion for Summary Judgment

✅ Motion to Dismiss Example:

In Ashcroft v. Iqbal, the Supreme Court ruled that the plaintiff’s allegations were too general to support a claim for discrimination. The motion to dismiss was granted because the complaint did not include sufficient facts to state a plausible claim for relief.

“The complaint fails to allege specific facts sufficient to show a plausible claim for discriminatory intent. The defendant moves to dismiss the case for failure to state a claim.”

✅ Motion for Summary Judgment Example:

In Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, the defendant moved for summary judgment, arguing that the plaintiff had failed to produce any evidence that the defendant’s product caused the plaintiff’s injuries. The court granted summary judgment because the plaintiff could not provide any evidence to prove their case.

“There is no genuine dispute of material fact regarding the causation of the plaintiff’s injuries. The defendant moves for summary judgment based on the lack of evidence supporting the plaintiff’s claims.”

🎯 These examples demonstrate how the timing and evidence presented are key to determining which motion to file.

6. Impact on Litigation Strategy

✅ Filing a motion to dismiss or motion for summary judgment can significantly impact the course of litigation:

• Motion to Dismiss: If successful, it can end the case early and avoid the costs of discovery and trial.

• Motion for Summary Judgment: If successful, it can resolve the case without a trial if the facts are clear and undisputed, saving time and legal fees.

Final Thoughts

Both motions to dismiss and motions for summary judgment are powerful tools that can shape the outcome of a case. A motion to dismiss can end the case early by challenging the legal sufficiency of the complaint, while a motion for summary judgment can terminate the case if there is no dispute over the facts. By understanding the distinctions and choosing the right tool at the right time, attorneys can effectively streamline litigation and reduce the costs of prolonged cases.

Let Legal Husk Help You Navigate Motions to Dismiss and Summary Judgment

Need help determining whether to file a motion to dismiss or summary judgment in your case? Legal Husk offers expert guidance to help you strategize and draft motions that will strengthen your position.

📌 Ready to file strategically and win?

👉 Visit:
🔗 legalhusk.com
🔗 legalhusk.com/services
🔗 legalhusk.com/about-us

File wisely. Litigate efficiently—Legal Husk.

📩 Ready for a court-ready Motion to Dismiss at a predictable price? Contact Legal Husk for expert support.